Freeze never thaws in Pokemon Red, Blue and Yellow
In Gen 1, frozen means frozen. There is no thaw roll in the game at all, and if the freeze lands in the turn your Pokemon used Hyper Beam, you do not even get a menu to switch out.
The short answer. In Pokemon Red, Blue and Yellow a frozen Pokemon never thaws on its own: the game has no thaw roll at all, so it stays frozen until a Fire-type move with a burn chance hits it, the other side uses Haze, or an Ice Heal, Full Heal or Full Restore cures it. Worse, if the other side freezes your Pokemon in the turn it used Hyper Beam, you get no battle menu at all, not even to switch, until it faints or something thaws it.
- Ice Beam, Blizzard and Ice Punch freeze 26 times in 256 when they hit, and never an Ice-type Pokemon.
- Fire Spin does not thaw. Only the Fire moves whose effect is a burn chance do: Ember, Fire Punch, Flamethrower, Fire Blast. They thaw every time, with no roll.
- Haze cures the other side's freeze, and that Pokemon loses its move for the turn.
- Tested in the game's own code in an emulator, in Red and Yellow. How I checked it.
What thaws a frozen Pokemon, and what does not
| What happens | Thawed? |
|---|---|
| A turn passes | No. "is frozen solid!" every turn, no roll |
| Hit by Ember, Fire Punch, Flamethrower or Fire Blast | Yes, every time: "Fire defrosted ...!" |
| Hit by Fire Spin | No. It is a trapping move, not a burn move |
| Hit by a Fire move while behind a Substitute | No. The effect stops at the Substitute |
| The other side uses Haze | Yes, but it loses its move that turn |
| Ice Heal, Full Heal, Full Restore | Yes |
| Switching out | No. It is still frozen when it comes back, and after the battle |
Frozen, turn by turn
A frozen Pokemon in Red, Blue or Yellow, and the same Pokemon under Gold, Silver and Crystal's rules, side by side. Pick what happens each turn.
Gold, Silver and Crystal roll a random byte at the end of each turn after the freezing one and thaw on 0 to 24: 25 in 256. Red, Blue and Yellow never roll.
The Hyper Beam freeze: no menu at all
This is the nasty one. At the start of every turn, the game decides whether to show your battle menu (MainInBattleLoop). It skips the menu while your Pokemon "needs to recharge" or is using Rage, because neither may choose anything. The recharge flag is cleared on the recharge turn, by the status check (CheckPlayerStatusConditions). But that check stops at "is frozen solid!" before it ever reaches the recharge flag. And when the other side freezes your Pokemon, unlike when you freeze theirs, the game does not clear the flag (pret: "hyper beam bits aren't reset for opponent's side").
So a Pokemon frozen in the turn it used Hyper Beam keeps the recharge flag forever, and the game never shows you a menu again while it is out: no Fight, no switching, no items, no running. It ends only when the Pokemon faints, or the other side thaws it with a burn-chance Fire move or Haze. Try the switches:
In my test a Tauros used Hyper Beam on a Lapras, and the Lapras's Ice Beam froze it in the same turn. For the next two turns the game asked for no input at all, only "TAUROS is frozen solid!", until Tauros fainted and the menu came back for Snorlax. A Primeape using Rage did exactly the same. The battler does this too: try it with the button below.
The code
; CheckPlayerStatusConditions, pret pokered engine/battle/core.asm .FrozenCheck bit FRZ, [hl] ; frozen? jr z, .HeldInPlaceCheck ld hl, IsFrozenText ; "is frozen solid!" call PrintText ... ld hl, ExecutePlayerMoveDone ; the turn ends here: no random number at all jp .returnToHL ... .HyperBeamCheck ; never reached while frozen bit NEEDS_TO_RECHARGE, [hl] ... res NEEDS_TO_RECHARGE, [hl]
The thaw is in CheckDefrost (engine/battle/effects.asm), which runs only as part of a move whose effect is a burn chance: "any fire-type move that has a chance inflict burn (all but Fire Spin) will defrost a frozen target". It checks the freeze before the burn roll, so the thaw needs no luck, and it runs after the Substitute check, so a Substitute stops it.
Which games
- Red, Blue and Yellow: the same routines (I compared Yellow's with Red's), and I ran both.
- Gold, Silver and Crystal: fixed.
HandleDefrostin pret's Gold and Crystal disassemblies rolls at the end of each turn and thaws on a roll under10 percent, 25 in 256, skipping the turn the Pokemon was frozen in. I read this; I did not run them.
How I checked it
- Read:
CheckPlayerStatusConditions,CheckEnemyStatusConditions,MainInBattleLoop,FreezeBurnParalyzeEffect,CheckDefrostandHazeEffect_in pret's pokered and pokeyellow. - Run in the game: Red and Yellow under the PyBoy emulator, with the battler's battle oracle setting the rolls. A Mew froze a Snorlax with Ice Beam; it stayed frozen through two Psychics and a Fire Spin and thawed when Ember hit it. A Cloyster froze a Snorlax and used Haze: the Snorlax was cured and did nothing that turn. A Tauros and a raging Primeape were frozen by a Lapras: no menu until they fainted. The battler's engine matched the game on every byte, message and battle state.
- Not tested: the items (read from the code), the Gen 2 games, and anything on a real Game Boy.
Questions
Does freeze wear off in Pokemon Red and Blue?
No. In Pokemon Red, Blue and Yellow a frozen Pokemon never thaws by itself: each turn the game prints is frozen solid and ends the Pokemon's turn, with no random chance to thaw. It stays frozen after the battle too, until it is healed.
How do you thaw a frozen Pokemon in Gen 1?
In battle, by being hit with a Fire-type move that has a chance to burn (Ember, Fire Punch, Flamethrower or Fire Blast), by the other side's Haze, or with an Ice Heal, Full Heal or Full Restore. Fire Spin does not thaw. Outside battle, the same items or a Pokemon Center.
What is the Hyper Beam freeze glitch?
If the other side freezes your Pokemon in the turn it used Hyper Beam (or before its recharge turn), the recharge flag is never cleared, and Red, Blue and Yellow skip your battle menu while that flag is set. So you get no menu at all: no Fight, no switching, no items, until the Pokemon faints or the other side thaws it with a Fire move or Haze. Rage does the same: a raging Pokemon that gets frozen is stuck too.
What are the odds of freezing in Gen 1?
Ice Beam, Blizzard and Ice Punch freeze 26 times in 256 when they hit (about 10%), and only if the target has no other status, no Substitute, and is not an Ice type.
Was freeze fixed in Gold and Silver?
Yes. In Gold, Silver and Crystal a frozen Pokemon has a 25 in 256 chance to thaw at the end of each turn after the one it was frozen in (HandleDefrost in pret's disassembly).
Was this tested on a real Game Boy?
No. I read the routines in pret's disassembly and ran the game's own code in the PyBoy emulator, in Red and in Yellow: a frozen Snorlax stayed frozen through Psychic and Fire Spin and thawed when Ember hit it, a Haze cure cost the Pokemon its turn, and a Tauros frozen right after Hyper Beam got no menu until it fainted. The battler's engine matched the game every time.